| Best & Fairest | Runners-up | |
|---|---|---|
| 1891 | Charles 'Butter' Laundry Best All-round Player | Tom Martin Second Best Player |
| 1899 | Harry 'Duxie' Gibson Most Brilliant Player | |
| 1900 | Harry 'Duxie' Gibson Best All-round Player | |
| 1906 | Austin 'Whelan' Carroll Best All-round Player | |
| 1910 | Joe 'Rangi' Bryant Best All-round Player | |
| 1911 | Ted 'Legs' Carroll Best All-round Player | |
| 1914 | Joe 'Rangi' Bryant Best All-round Player | |
| 1920 | Bill Toole Best Player | |
| 1925 | Jack Antonio Snr Most Consistent | |
| 1926 | Ed Joyce Most Popular | |
| 1930 | Ernie Verdon | Ed Joyce |
| 1932 | Arthur Perkins | |
| 1933 | Roy Copley | |
| 1934 | Ernie Verdon | |
| 1935 | Charlie Hamilton | |
| 1936 | Eric Feltscheer | Dan Kennedy |
| 1937 | Russell 'Ruck' O'Neill | Aub McRae |
| 1938 | Alan Neal | |
| 1946 | Fred Drever | |
| 1947 | Frank Parker | Arthur Clark |
| 1948 | Arthur Clark | Bill Walker |
| 1949 | Ted Whitfield | Lochie Kent |
| 1950 | Jack 'Cooka' Clark | Dick Hellyer |
| 1951 | Ron Jory | Ted Whitfield |
| 1952 | Allan James | Reg Bates |
| 1953 | Bob Ord | Jack Antonio |
| 1954 | Doug Donaldson | Jack Antonio |
| 1955 | Jim Bonner | Jack 'Cooka' Clark |
| 1956 | Jack Antonio | Jack 'Cooka' Clark |
| 1957 | Arthur Clark | Jim Bonner |
| 1958 | Jim Bonner | Arthur Clark |
| 1959 | John 'Nocca' Nailon | Bill Gleeson |
| 1960 | John 'Nocca' Nailon, Graeme White | Gerry Brennan |
| 1961 | Brian 'Muncher' Molony | Arthur Mahoney |
| 1962 | Jim Pearce | Brian 'Muncher' Molony |
| 1963 | Jim Bonner | Ken Clark |
| 1964 | Jim Bonner | Maurie Sheehan |
| 1965 | Barry Price | Terry Brady |
| 1966 | Kevin 'Darky' Tassell | Rod Flavell |
| 1967 | John Perkins | Ron Ward |
| 1968 | Laurie Stephens | Peter Christie |
| 1969 | Barry Grinter | Laurie Stephens, Graeme Sladdin, Leo Mooney |
| 1970 | Leo Mooney | Kevin Westrup |
| 1971 | Leo Mooney | Peter Christie |
| 1972 | Greg Kent | Kevin Westrup |
| 1973 | Laurie Stephens | Bruce Olver |
| 1974 | Leo Mooney | Laurie Stephens |
| 1975 | Wilf Dickeson | Terry Davis |
| 1976 | Greg Kent | Terry Mooney |
| 1977 | Lindsay Beck | Terry Harrison |
| 1978 | Greg Kent | Terry Harrison |
| 1979 | Greg Kent | Lindsay Beck |
| 1980 | Terry Harrison | John Mulqueen |
| 1981 | Colin Thompson | Brendan Maher |
| 1982 | Colin Thompson | Robert Harricks |
| 1983 | Murray McKinnis | Robert Harricks |
| 1984 | Robert Harricks | Craig Heard |
| 1985 | Allister Williamson | Bruce Vallance |
| 1986 | Stuart McKinnis | Michael Hosking |
| 1987 | Scott Astbury | Stuart McKinnis |
| 1988 | Michael Hosking | Michael Todd |
| 1989 | Greg Bradshaw | Craig Turner |
| 1990 | Greg Cox | Greg Bradshaw |
| 1991 | David Clark | Geoff 'Frosty' Miller |
| 1992 | Glenn Antonio | Brad Ward |
| 1993 | Tim Shea | David Jennings |
| 1994 | Allister Williamson | Jason Harvey |
| 1995 | Glenn Antonio | Allister Williamson |
| 1996 | Bart Molony | Allister Williamson |
| 1997 | Ben Ingleton | Allister Williamson |
| 1998 | Shane Hitchcock | Allister Williamson, Heath Whiting |
| 1999 | Paul McLoughlan | Brad Keilar |
| 2000 | Matthew Jackson | Dale Bligh |
| 2001 | Matthew Jackson | Nigel Edwards |
| 2002 | Dale Bligh | Paul McLoughlan |
| 2003 | Matthew Jackson | Dale Bligh |
| 2004 | Tim Shea | Paul McLoughlan |
| 2005 | Matthew Jackson | Craig Cooper |
| 2006 | Dale Bligh | Matthew Jackson |
| 2007 | Michael Fratin | Dale Bligh |
| 2008 | Alan Batchelor | Ben Harrison |
| 2009 | Ben Harrison | Alan Batchelor |
| 2010 | Lachlan Molloy | Toby Reid |
| 2011 | Ryan Bates | Jake Williamson |
| 2012 | Jake Williamson | Luke Todd |
| 2013 | Aaron Searle | Alan Batchelor |
| 2014 | Daniel Mendes | Jack Ganley |
| 2015 | Jack Ganley | Alan Batchlelor |
| 2016 | Ryan Bates | Jake Williamson |
| 2017 | Jack Ganley | Tom Mills |
| 2018 | Daniel Mendes | Harry Ganley |
| 2019 | Daniel Mendes | Jack Ganley |
| 2020 | COVID 19 | |
| 2021 | Tom Mills | Liam Arnott, Jake Williamson |
| 2022 | Matt Hutchesson | Ben Taylor |
| 2023 | Cody Lindsay | Ben Taylor |
| 2024 | Tom Williamson | Jake Robinson |
| 2025 | Tom Williamson | Ben Taylor |